|
| |
-
-
Competitive Advantage through Competitive Intelligence
- By: L. Scott Harrell,
CompassPoint
Investigations
-
- How well do you make
business decisions? Would you make better decisions if you
could rub a crystal ball and see into the future? For those
of you who are skeptical of Dionne Warwick's ability to help
you discover the next great innovation in your industry
through the Psychic Friends Network, try competitive
intelligence. While I cannot promise to out-predict the
mythical wizard Merlin, I can help you can gain valuable
foresight into market trends, buyer behavior and your
competitors' plans by employing creative techniques for
gathering information from public records, interviews and
physical surveillance and then using sophisticated methods
of analysis to combine numerous pieces of uncommon
information into strategic recommendations for your business
(or a client's business). All for a lot less than the $2.99
per minute the psychic hotlines are charging.
-
- Intelligence is uncommon
information analyzed for its strategic implications.
Thousands of years ago, the brilliant Chinese military
strategist Sun Tsu stressed the vital role of military
intelligence to gain a "foreknowledge" of the enemy's plans
and the use of counterintelligence to deceive your enemy.
This combination of foresight and deception provides a
strategic advantage in both a military and commercial
setting.
-
- While military intelligence
is gathered through spying, commercial or competitive
intelligence is gathered through a thorough review of public
records for hidden information, excellent interviewing
skills and keen physical observation, all geared toward
predicting the future plans of your competitors and
customers by understanding their behavior and thought
processes.
-
- For example, a restaurant
located in a busy urban area operates in an intensely
competitive environment. While good food at a good price are
prerequisites to success ("order necessary criteria"), you
need something to put you over the top ("order winning
criteria"). A review of your competitors' filings with the
planning and zoning commission may provide you with critical
insight into future plans. Applications for construction
permits suggest expansion, which means shorter waits for
customers, an order winning criteria. Requests for no
parking zones in front of the restaurant may be for valet
parking, an order winning criteria, especially in
overcrowded urban areas.
-
- The really good competitive
intelligence professionals are extremely creative and go
well beyond public records. For example, getting a job at
the competing restaurant as a bus boy would allow you to:
(a) calculate a reasonable estimate of that day's revenues
by dividing the total tips by 15%-20% (working backwards
from his tips from the servers); (b) develop a list of
suppliers; (c) uncover operational strengths and weakness
that can be benchmarked against your business and industry
averages; and (d) gain valuable insight into the thought
process of the managers.
-
- This is very different from
spying, which is illegal. A so called industrial spy would
rip the hard drive out the restaurant's PC, tap the phone,
bug the office or steal files. A competitive intelligence
professional is merely paying great attention to publicly
observable events, having innocent conversations with
customers, suppliers and employees, and viewing public
filings to create a profile of the business and its decision
making processes.
- employees, and reviewing
public filings to create a profile of the business and its
decision making processes.
-
- Competitive intelligence can
be used not only to predict and counteract your competitor’s
strategic moves, but also to better understand your
customers and your market, allowing you to become the market
innovator. Marketing mavens Al Reis and Jack Trout, in
their book Positioning: How To Be Seen and Heard in an
Overcrowded Marketplace, emphasize the importance of being
first. In a society where consumers are bombarded by
competing, groundless claims of who is the best, what people
remember is who was first. If you are the first restaurant
to offer free valet parking in an overcrowded neighborhood,
every one else is viewed as a follower, no matter how much
better they may do it. Therefore, good, timely intelligence
about the market in which you operate is critical to
innovation, strategic positioning and effective business
decision making.
-
- According to the Society of
Competitive Intelligence Professionals, only seven percent
of large corporations have a formalized, full scale,
competitive intelligence capability. For smaller companies,
the figure drops to approximately five percent. If you are
looking for a competitive advantage, try looking into the
mind of your customers and competitors through competitive
intelligence.
-
- If you are looking for
additional revenue through your own investigations agency,
why not offer competitive intelligence to your business
clients? I had a case not too long ago where a friend wanted
to start a commercial landscaping service and he asked me
how he could jumpstart his marketing and advertising. The
solution was immediately clear to me: go to the consumers of
such services first and offer to do the job better and a
little less expensive than the current provider (again,
"order necessary criteria"). So he hired my investigation
agency to pick 3 commercial landscaping companies to follow
and develop a client list. We not only developed an
extensive client list for him but obtained copies of their
marketing materials, products used, service fees and client
points of contact (the decision makers). Armed with this
information my friend then simply approached the potential
clients with a better offer.
-
- Out of the 71 service
consumers we identified, he landed 18 of them and had
instant start up revenue; 11 of these 18 were clients of the
same landscaping company, so we both realized that there was
an obvious service problem that was exploitable. We focused
our efforts on that service provider for 2 more days and our
client ended up gaining an additional 6 accounts. Our cost
to him for services ended up being a little over $5,720 but
the 24 accounts he picked up paid for our services in less
than 2 months. We have replicated this type of service now
well over a dozen times and are making this a featured
service within my agency.
-
-
- To learn more about
competitive intelligence we recommend the following links:
- The Society of Competitive
Intelligence Professionals
http://www.scip.org/
- The Axioms of Competitive
Intelligence
http://www.combsinc.com/chapt2.htm
- Wikipedia Article on
Competitive Intelligence:
http://www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_intelligence
-
-
-
|
| |

|